You're probably thinking of Duncan's older "Art of Classical Guitar", which is indeed more analytical and philosophical, and which I recommended above as a supplement to a method for those adults interested in going deeper into the theory behind the technique. It was a popular college level textbook, according to Duncan.tormodg wrote:I have used Noad's book since forever (around 1990), they are great - I still play several pieces from the books.
Duncan's method is excellent, but more philosophical. I enjoyed it a lot when I was a student 25 years ago - it took me down a different, deeper path to understanding how to play and enjoy classical guitar.
I think Duncan's books are best enjoyed when you reach a higher level and have more experience.
so much for your comment and in suggesting the Sagreras method and for explaining the difference in the Noad method! I will definitely keep this in mind.ashworth wrote:I've been using both the Sagreras and the Noad (and also the Carcassi) by turns. If I had to recommend one, I'd say the Sagreras. A couple of things about the Noad method, excellent though it is—I do find that it progresses pretty fast in terms of difficulty, which has led me to some frustration at times. Also the repertoire is heavily weighted toward Renaissance music, (at least as far as I've gotten, which is the latter part of book 1). That is great if that's your liking, but it isn't my particular interest.
The Sagreras contains some really nice pieces that are written specifically for the guitar and what I find to be a more suitable rate of progress with the difficulty level. But again, the Noad is certainly an excellent method in many respects; there is much more helpful text and explanation than in the Sagreras, for one thing.
Ah...you're right of course! Thank you for pointing that out.robert e wrote:You're probably thinking of Duncan's older "Art of Classical Guitar" [...] But the OP is asking about the more recent "A Modern Approach", which is a method book for the complete beginner to get up and playing quickly. And suitable, I think, for kids as well as adults.
Users browsing this forum: Adrian Allan, CommonCrawl [Bot], johnd, Lawler, sitnivez, Stephen Kenyon and 14 guests