What reverb do you apply? I would not have thought of compressing the sound given the already limited dynamics of the guitar - why do you do this and how much?
It's the standard reverb in Audacity. In the picture are the settings of the reverb I use. I duplicate the track, add the reverb to the new one, lower its volume by 7dB and then mix the tracks into one. After that I use compression 2:1. I tried it on a piece and liked the effect, although at first I didn't notice Audacity also normalizes to 0dB at same time. In the screenshot you can see the compressed (first part, including normalizing) and uncompressed (second, with normalizing). I can't see any difference, so maybe I should go back to just normalizing.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.